Florence Kay Butler Hendricks had a daughter that our family did not know about until after both Grand and Florence were dead.

The Hendricks family did not know that Carrie existed until after both Grant and Florence had died. Several of Grant's sons went back to Indiana to attend to some gravestone issues and discovered this history. They were devastated to find they had a half sister they did not know about, and she was now dead. This is the history we have manage to uncover about the lost member of our clan.

The last we could find in Census about Carrie is that her Mother and her lived with Lawson and Samantha Allan.
Lawson D Allen was a prominant farmer and stockholder in the area (240 acres). His wife Samantha died in 1883 and he remarried to Margaret Stephens in 1886. Lawson & Samantha had 5 children (Loton H, Estella, William P, Adam, and Roy Forest) all died before his biography was published in 1894 except Loton H. There is no mention of Carrie L so we can assume she was not officially adopted by the family.

Then, both disappear.

We discovered after much research, her history.

The marriage of Samuel Fishburn to Miss Carrie Butler occurred at the home of John Daufel at noon Wednesday, 6/28/1899, Rev. Myers officiating. Both the bride and groom are well and favorably know here, and we join their many friends in extending congratulations.

Carrie Lee Butler b. 1879 d. 1914 (infection)
m. Samuel O Fishburn
...
1. Hazel B Fishburn b. 1912 d. 2006 Leesburg, Ind
m1. Bef. 1940 - Calvan Zartman
m2. Bef. 1960 - Herschel Hibschman
1-1. Daughter
1-2. Son
1-3. Daughter
*Unsure which husband these children were with (would assume Zartman)
...
2. Esther "Carrie" Inez Fishburn b. 1901 Argos, Ind. d. 1940 Argos, Ind (illness 10 days)
m. 5-21-1921 - William "Guy" Voreis (d. 1960)
2-1. Carrie Donnabell Voreis b. 1922 d. 1989
m. Luebker
2-2. Robert L Voreis b. 1925
m. ??
*I believe he married and had children because there is a listing with Sr. after his name.
2-3. Patricia L Voreis b. 1929
m. Leslie Leon Williams b. 1923 d. 1989
2-3-1. Joann Williams
m. Mr. Maze
2-3-1-1. Son Maze
2-3-2. Cheryl Williams
m. Mr. Nieburt
2-3-3. Gary Williams
m. ??
2-3-3-1. Son Williams
2-3-3-2. Daughter Williams
2-3-4. Duane Paul Williams b. 1947 d. 1997 Bremen, Ind. (illness)
m. Donna
2-3-4-1. Christopher Duane Williams b. 1979 d. 1995 Hamlet, Ind.
2-3-4-2. Karen Williams b. Aft 1979
...
3. Lowell Vern Fishburn b. Abt 1905/6

The daughter born July 24, 1879 in Poplar Grove , IN to Florence Kay & Benjamin B. Butler was named Carrie Lee Butler. Carrie married Samuel O. Fishburn who was born 1871 and died April 18, 1960. Samuel's father was Samuel Fishburn who died July 8, 1903. Carrie & Samuel had three children: 2 daughters & 1 son. Carrie died Feb. 19, 1914 of septicemia in Green Twp., Marshall Co., IN. Carrie's obituary from the Argos, IN paper, 2/1914. Carrie Butler Fishburn was born July 24, 1879 in the vicinity of Poplar Grove church and grew to womanhood near Jordan church in the home of Mr. John Daufel. She passed from this life Feb. 19, 1914, aged 34 years, 6 months and 25 days. She was united in marriage with Samuel Fishburn, June 28, 1899. To this union were born two daughters and a son who with their father remain to feel a loss so deep, that nothing can repay except a better world than this, beyond the borders of time. Mrs. Fishburn gave her heart to God when she was 15 years old and united with the Jordan Baptist church April 26, 1895, of which she remained a member until her Savior called her to the church triumphant. Her life though short was full of good always having a pleasant and hopeful disposition. She was loved and respected by all who knew her and in her death we all feel a deep sense of loss. She will be most missed in the home where she was a kind considerate mother, a true wife and to all else a true friend. We feel that our loss is Heaven's gain. A loved one, from us, has gone away, Removed from mortal eye; yet not extinct, she holds her away, In glory in the sky. Funeral services were held at Poplar Grove Sunday at 11 a.m. conducted by Rev. Albert L. Vermillion, with interment in adjacent cemetery.

Samuel O. FISHBURN, a resident of the Argos vicinity for many years, died at 6:20 p.m. Monday in his home 1 1/2 miles south of Argos on U.S. 31 after an illness of two years. He was 88 years old.

Born in Mifflin, O., Nov. 25, 1871, he was the son of Samuel and Margaret McCLURE FISHBURN. At an early age, he moved to Denver, Ind., and from there to Marshall county. He was a retired farmer.

On June 28, 1899, Mr. Fishbrn married Carrie L. BUTLER, who died Feb. 19, 1914. On Aug. 31, 1929, he married Della Pearl BODEY, who survives.

Also surviving are a daughter, Mrs. Herschel (Hazel) HIBSCHMAN, Warsaw; a son, Lowell [FISHBURN], Littletown, Colo; eight grandchildren; thirteen great grandchildren; a sister, Mrs. Cora NEWCOMB, Fullton, N.Y., and a brother, Arthur [FISHBURN], Culver.

Services will be at 2 p.m. Thursday in the Grossman funeral home at Argos with the Rev. Fred CROWN officiating. Burial will be in the Poplar Grove cemetery near Argos. Friends may call at the funeral home after 7 p.m. today.

HE HAD REMARRIED AFTER CARRIE'S DEATH AND HERE IS THE OBIT OF HIS SECOND WIFE

Della P. Fishburn
Mrs. Della P. FISHBURN, 72, R.R. 1, Argos, died of pneumonia at 9:45 a.m. Tuesday at Plymouth Parkview hospital after a two-week illness.
The daughter of Henry and Viella MARKLEY ZENTZ, she was born near Nappanee Aug. 21, 1894. She had been a resident of the Argos community a half century, moving there
from Bremen. She was married to Arley BUDEY in 1921. He died in 1925. Se married Samuel O. FISHBURN in 1929. He died in 1960. She was a member of the First Brethren church at Tiosa.
Survivors are four sisters, Mrs. Dora KOONTZ and Mrs. Ada HASS, both of Bremen, and Mrs. Eva LAWSON and Miss Hazel ZENTZ, both of Elkhart; two brothers, Harvey ZENTZ,
Bremen, and Claude ZENTZ, Argos; a step-daughter, Mrs. Hazel HIBSCHMAN, Warsaw; a stepson, Lowell FISHBURN, Littleton, Colo., and eight step-grandchildren. Two sisters and a stepdaughter preceded in death.
Funeral services will be Friday at 2 p.m. at the Grossman funeral home in Argos with the Rev. Gene ECKERLEY officiating. Burial will be in the Argos Maple Grove cemetery. Friends may call at the funeral home after 7 p.m. today.

Mrs. Guy BOREIS [VOREIS?], aged 37, died at 12:30 p.m. Tuesday in the Kelly hospital at Argos after an illness of ten days due to complications. Her home was on West William street in Argos.
The deceased was a life resident of Marshall county and was born on a farm southwest of Argos on December 12, 1902. Her parents were Samuel and Carrie (Butler) FISHBURN.
In a ceremony performed at Argos on May 21, 1921, she was married to Mr. Boreis Mrs. Boreis was a member of the Christian church at Argos.
Survivors are the husband, two daughters, Donna Belle [BOREIS] and Patricia [BOREIS], a son Robert Lowell [BOREIS], all at home, father, of Argos, a sister, Mrs. Hazel ZARTMAN, Argos and a brother Lowell FISHBURN of Plymouth.
The body was taken to the Grossman funeral home where the last rites will be held at 2 p.m. Frday with Rev. Ernest TREBER, pastor of the Argos Christian church officiating. Burial will be made in the New Oak Hill cemetery at Plymouth.
The body was returned to the Boreis home from the Grossman apartments this afternoon where it will remain until the hour of the last rites.